Sunny was involved in many successful business ventures in his lifetime. . Some basic help and starters when you have to write a tribute to someone you love. The sentences Sands imposed on the three defendants convicted by a jury about a year ago are by far the most severe criminal sanctions ever imposed on American food executives over food safety. In addition to his wife, he is survived by his children, Stewart (Gloria Beth) Parnell, Hugh (Ann) Parnell, Mike (Jean) Parnell, and Beth (Jimmy) Falwell; five WebBeth Falwell in Raleigh, NC Current Address 91*** **** Ct, RALEIGH, NC 27617-8421 View Address Year Built: 2001 Baths: 3.00 Style: CONVENTIONAL Property Lot Size: 13504 SF Building Area: 3280 Owner: falwell, james c & beth p Total Market Value: $553,993 Sale Price: $535,000 Home Value: $535 Purchase Price: $535 +Edit Past Address WebAs Stewart Parnells sister, Beth Falwell, entered a courtroom Monday to learn of her brothers sentence for his involvement in a 2008 salmonella outbreak, she held a death Mr. Parnell is a perfect illustration of the fallacy underlying the claims of laissez-faire purists. Food producers in most states are not required to alert health regulators if internal tests show possible contamination at their plants. Parnell, who for decades ran the Virginia-based Peanut Corp. of America, was found guilty last year on more than 70 criminal charges, including knowingly shipping tainted food across state lines, obstruction of justice, conspiracy and wire fraud. The deadly Salmonella Typhimurium outbreak PCA products caused back in 2008-09 will take its place in history, with nine deaths and probably thousands sickened. Beth Falwell says her family is asking the people for the benefit of the doubt, when it comes to the peanut product salmonella investigation. Thanks for helping bring about the end of the world so you could make huge $$$$$. Youve changing as We the People watch from being a figurative tool, to a being a literal tool a teaching tool. FBI investigators raided PCA plant in Blakely, Georgia after linking it to a nationwide salmonella outbreak. Published by The News & Advance from May 4 to May 5, 2012. Charles Stewart Parnell (circa 1880) On Monday, February 2, 1880, Charles Stewart Parnell addressed the American Congress. To plant trees in memory, please visit the. "If the FDA discovered that there was an issue with this product inspection, why didn't they follow up on it? Join Facebook to connect with Beth Falwell and others you may know. Falwell denied that company engaged in lab shopping and insisted that company officials would never knowingly distribute contaminated products. Parnell approved shipments despite such warnings. He has yet to take responsibility. WebAs Stewart Parnells sister, Beth Falwell, entered a courtroom Monday to learn of her brothers sentence for his involvement in a 2008 salmonella outbreak, she held a death certificate He will really be missed by everyone. Anyone can read what you share. Jeanie, Dear Zelda and children, I was saddened to learn of Hugh's passing. Beth Falwell, sister of Peanut Corporation of America's president Stewart Parnell and daughter of the company's founder, denied the company went "lab shopping" and said the company would never knowingly distribute contaminated products. In what the Food and Drug Administration is characterizing as one of the largest recalls in recent history, numerous types of products containing peanuts are being recalled in the United States. Calvin Falwell, for example, is a businessman and president of the Lynchburg Mets, the Class A team that once had Dwight Gooden on its roster. On Friday in U.S. District Court in Albany, Georgia, Judge W. Louis Sands said Parnell faces a possible prison sentence of 9,636 months, or 803 years. "My hope is that we can even have a change of venue granted and have it somewhere other than here.". Dear Hugh & Ann, we are very sorry to hear of the passing of your Dad. So sorry for you loss. As the salmonella outbreak spread, inspectors from the Food and Drug Administration descended on the Georgia plant and documented a litany of unsanitary conditions, including mold, roaches, dirty equipment, holes big enough to allow rodents inside and a failure to separate raw and cooked products. . MORE: What the salmonella trial sentencing means for food. Congressman Henry Waxman (D-CA) has announced he will hold a Congressional hearing February 11 before the House Energy and Commerce Committee to investigate the matter. As the reality of the 28-year sentence set in, the family reflected on the memories they have as they maintain their commitment to fighting for their father. We had a lot of great times in the old days at SML. The lake, Lynchburg, and The Outer Banks has lost a friend to all. It's surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning. The Falwells came to Virginia in the 1600s, moving west county by county until they settled in Lynchburg in the 1850s, according to Jerry Falwell Jr., who has completed a family history. WebHome; 2024 baseball team rankings. To wit: Get it while you can. (Kevin Clark/The Washington Post), Former Peanut Corporation of America Owner Stewart Parnell is heading to prison after a jury convicted him of knowingly shipping out salmonella-contaminated peanut butter and hiding the evidence. "It's just unreal that he's also the person that's sitting on the other side of the bar.. when you see him in orange behind glass.". #PeanutTrial @WFXL, Man at the podium struggling to make it through his recall of events. The Falwells are not traditionally religious people. Falwell, her voice quivering with emotion, asked for patience while the investigations run the course. David Kessler's top 4 tips for dealing with holiday grief. most MBA programs, including those in the Ivy League taught a different lesson. I've always had alot of respect for Hugh . This page was last edited on 24 December 2013, at 20:49. The other Falwells are involved in secular businesses, but Jerry Jr. said they do not have the power in the community that Carey Falwell wielded. Too often those running businesses in the hastiness of their greed, neglect to think out their actions to their logical conclusions. Another member of the Jerry Falwell learned religion from his mother, Helen Beasley Falwell, a fundamentalist who used to turn on . The family from Virginia was at the center of a federal investigation since early 2009. The outbreak ultimately sickened at least 714 people in dozens of states and contributed to a total of nine deaths, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Jimmy and Tammy Faye where have you gone? Right now its not a law maybe it should be but he didnt break any laws, Falwell said. The social sciences took a back seat to Republican economic theories during the past thirty years, aided I believe in large part by the ascendancy of fundamentalist clergy who have indoctrinated large portions of the population with prosperity theology, the bastard child of religion and materialism which treats the accumulation of wealth as the divinitys reward for virtuous living. On Thursday, Congressman Henry Waxman (D-CA) announced the first congressional hearing on the outbreak. Peanut Corporation of America owner Stewart Parnell has invoked his privilege against self-incrimination to refuse testimony before Congress. "We have strong faith in God. Beth says companies like Kelloggs would not have done business with PCA, if they found poor conditions. He said that the acts involved were driven by the desire for profit and to protect profits despite known risks, something which he notedis commonly and accurately referred to as greed. Sands has presided over the criminal case since February 2013, when Stewart Parnell and four other defendants were named in a 76-count felony indictment involvingcharges of conspiracy, fraud, and shipping food that was contaminated and misbranded. On Monday, Sands presided over the end of the case, at least from the trial courts perspective. All rights reserved, Peanut executive's daughters speak after salmonella trial sentence, Man charged with murder in 2020 Brooks Co. football players death. Brady Dennis is a Pulitzer Prize-winning national reporter for The Washington Post, focusing on the environment and public health. AGE View Full Report AGE Phone Address View Full Report AGE View Full Report AGE Phone Address View Full Report Powered by Whitepages Premium AGE 60s Beth N Falwell Murray, KY . But his daughters insisted that happened because of pressure to keep quiet during the investigation. Last year, a pair of Colorado brothers, Eric and Ryan Jensen, agreed to plead guilty to misdemeanor charges and received five years probation after a 2011 listeria outbreak linked to their cantaloupe farm contributed to 33 deaths. Major customers, including Kelloggs Co., routinely send their own inspectors to PCAs plants, she said, and those companies would not have continued to do business with PCA if they had found major problems. My sympathy to the whole family. The FDA says PCA shipped each out after retesting did not find salmonella. She's begging the judge to give her sons the recognition they deserve. . Members of the family owning the peanut processing plant in Georgia identified as the source of a salmonella outbreak say reports that the facility was filthy are "exaggerated," and they insist the company didn't break any laws, msnbc.com reports. U.S. District Court Judge W. Louis Sands said that, in the end, the case was not about murder, even though nine people died from the poisoned peanuts. A local television reporter tweeting from the courtroom said Parnells own mother spoke on his behalf. The best poems for funerals, memorial services., and cards. Hundreds fell ill, and at least nine died. But others showed up to defend Parnells character. Beths father Hugh Parnell's younger sister, Beth, is married to Jimmy Falwell, a cousin of the late Rev. Articles presented on Wikinews reflect the specific time at which they were written and published, and do not attempt to encompass events or knowledge which occur or become known after their publication. Lawyers for Michael Parnell also plan to appeal. Also survived by two brothers and a sister: William Parnell, HC Parnell, and Sally Kluge; and. [The most severe punishment ever for a food-related crime]. Weve been flying out of it for 40 years, he said, but Jerry Falwell has outgrown the strip. Parnell ordered the shipment of peanut paste contaminated by salmonella that not only killed nine people, but also produced one of the biggest recalls in food safety history. In the 21st century, it's not just urns and gravestones anymore. #PeanutTrial @WFXL, "I would like to address Stewart. PCA president Stewart Parnell is expected to testify, as well as representatives from two labs that PCA used for testing. A Dangerous Herbicide, a Late Flu Season and the Octuplets Troubled Home, https://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/health/2rounds.html. He was the husband of Zelda Morris Parnell for 58 years. As of Thursday, the Virginia Department of Health says there are 21 cases of this type of salmonella being reported in the Commonwealth. May you and he be at peace in this difficult time. U.S. federal inspectors stated salmonella was found in 12 instances at the plant. #PeanutTrial @WFXL, Parnell's mother, Zelda is at the podium! WebStewart Parnell married Ada Jane Florence Parnell (born Channells). Parnells Will Spend the Night in Federal Lockup, Face Many More Why didn't they take a closer look at this facility?" Although his sentence is less than the maximum, it is the longest sentence ever in a food poisoning case. He added via Twitter, This sentence is going to send a stiff, cold wind through board rooms across the U.S. Marler, who represented most of those injured by PCA peanut products in separate civil litigation, said it is not uncommon to see prosecutors pass on taking criminal action after foodborne illness outbreaks. Kilgore and Lightsey are scheduled tobe sentenced Oct. 1 and likely will do better than the trio who went to trial. We can't do that,'" said Adams. It's all worth it," said Robinson. Unless you are experienced as an estate executor, you probably should hire an attorney. A 76-count indictment followed four years later and then a lengthy criminal trial that resulted in guilty verdicts on nearly all counts for Parnell, his food broker brother Michael Parnell, and plant Quality Assurance Manager Mary Wilkerson. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. Born in Detroit, Michigan, he was a son of the late Hugh Alfred Parnell and Estelle Miller Parnell. Note her married name: In an interview Thursday, Beth Falwell, the sister of PCA President Stewart Parnell and daughter of PCAs founder, vigorously defended the company, saying the FDAs report was flawed and exaggerated.. Parnell was sentenced in 2015 to a 28-year prison term, which he is currently serving at a federal prison in South Carolina. asked Representative Rosa DeLauro (D-CT). Mespo, Daughter of Peanut Corp. founder speaks about salmonella case. I firmly believe that God is not finished with my dad yet. Hence unbridled free-market capitalism has become the new religion and Wall Street its temple. Earlier this year, former Iowa egg executive Austin Jack DeCoster and his son received a prison sentence of several months for their role in a 2010 salmonella outbreak that sickened thousands of people; they are appealing the sentence. What is remarkable is how many many fall into this trap as shown by Roger Clemens, Barry Bonds, and others. Malaysia banned paraquat in 2006 but reversed itself after growers demanded to use the cheap herbicide, which workers carry in canisters on their backs as they spray the fields. Anything he can do to help a Christian organization is good work.. Sign up for our newsletter to keep reading. She, along with Hopefully, this kind of prosecution will motivate the Congress to fully fund FDA efforts to prevent such tragedies., (To sign up for a free subscription to Food Safety News, clickhere. All great points that needed expression. Read the link. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on. The mandate for a business is to make profit. ), CDC declares Salmonella outbreak linked to sprouts over, Canned shrimp recalled over reports of swelling, leaking and bursting cans, Mislabeling and consumer complaint leads to public health alert for pasta sauce, Enoki mushrooms recalled after testing finds Listeria, Food Safety: the morning after the morning after, The matrix has failed, the system has crashed; FDA needs a new food approach, Publishers Platform: Twenty-eight minutes with FDA Commissioner Califf. U.S. Sands allowed family and friends of the Parnells and Wilkerson to give testimony as character witnesses, and time was also set aside for victims of the outbreak to make statements. Stewart passed away. Allow me to clarifyand to ponder. You can cancel at any time! Grief researchers say holding that missing funeral service, even a year or more later, can still help us heal. The FDA also says its inspectors found mold, a leaking roof, and other sanitary problem at the plant, and has since shut it down. A strong sentence is what he deserves., [Salmonella outbreaks expose weaknesses in USDA oversight]. Stewart Parnell, a former peanut executive convicted for his role in a nationwide salmonella outbreak in 2008 and 2009 that killed nine people, was sentenced The recall affects over 430 products containing peanut paste or peanut butter from the PCA plant. Jerry Falwell built a national following with his Old Time Gospel Hour television broadcast and his Moral Majority political organization, and he is in the thick of the fight over the PTL ministry. Randy Napier was among those in the courtroom Monday. Although it is certainly interesting that unbridled free markets dont apply when elites lose money on their investments or when they are writing the laws for Congress in the first place. Please note that due to our archival policy, we will not alter or update the content of articles that are archived, but will only accept requests to make grammatical and formatting corrections. The episode helped fuel a push by the Obama administration for the first overhaul of the nations food-safety system in generations. "We had written several apologies that we wanted to put out and the PR, and the attorneys at that time, said, 'No. Hezekiah Carey Falwell moved onto a 1,000-acre tract of land east of town, still in the family hands, Jerry Jr. said from his home in Charlottesville, where he recently graduated from the University of Virginia law school. The other lesson we should have learned, is that the regulations and the authority of the FDA needs to be changed, so that the FDA clearly has the power to FORCE a recall of tainted food and drugs, rather than requesting a processor to do the right thing. Mollie asks: Did the company knowingly send out products with salmonella?, Beth responds: Not to my knowledge, no.. #PeanutTrial @WFXL, I really struggled with trying to forgive this guy, because he claims no responsibility whatsoever. Heres a little story from the local Lynchburg newspaper about the PCA owners daughter asking for understanding. Beth Falwell, daughter of PCA's founder Hugh Parnell, told WSLS-TV, the NBC affiliate in Roanoke, Virginia, in a statement Thursday that her brother Stewart Parnell who currently runs the company would not knowingly harm his customers. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. . The outbreak resulted in one of the largest recalls in the nations history, with PCA recalling everything it had produced since 2007. Zelda, Beth, Stewart, Michael, and Hugh you are all in my thoughts and prayers. WebParnell's younger sister, Beth, is married to Jimmy Falwell, a cousin of the late Rev. #PeanutTrial @WFXL. Prayers of comfort are with you. Go with God. Jeff Almer was among those arguing that Parnell doesnt deserve mercy from the legal system. Peanut Corp says its working to make sure the problem never happens again. After we published my article about former Peanut Corporation of America CEO, Stewart Parnell, on Monday, I heard from one of his family members, who did not want to be identified by name: Mr. If youre in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist. Then Samuel Lightsey, the former Blakely plant manager who was at Stewart Parnells side when the pair decided not to testify before Congress in the midst of the 2008-09 outbreak, also cut a deal. Stewart and Michael Parnell will beguests of the U.S. Bureau of Prisons tonight (Monday, Sept. 21, 2015). Mollie: The FDA said there were roaches in the plant., Beth responds: im not saying that there werent, but Im saying its a food manufacturing plant. They were real wealthy and looked down on religion.. She is survived by her husband of 61 years, Charles Stewart Parnell; thre Michael Parnell, a former company supervisor and Stewart Parnells brother, was convicted on fewer counts and faces a potential sentence of more than 20 years in prison. Kilgore and Lightsey were key government witnesses during the trial, testifying for about 10 days and helping prosecutors get much of their evidence properly introduced. Acknowledging that the FDA may have found roaches at the Blakely plant, she added, Its a food manufacturing plant, you know? We'll help you find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult time. Stewart Parnell had already established himself as greedy and avaricious, yesterday just established that he is a coward. She, along with her brother Betty Lee Parnell, age 83, a resident of Maurertown, Virginia peacefully passed away on March 31, 2015 in Warrenton, Virginia. The only question is his liberty at this point. We pray for peace for you & your family. The emails portray Parnell as concerned only about delay and loss of money rather than the health of his customers. Let me know if I can do anything to help. IE 11 is not supported. The number one requirement for peace is that people be fed, not poisoned. Youve got it coming and then some. "Just ship him to jail" is what one family member said. The most likely charge that they faced was not from the original allegations but their testimony before Congress, the grand jury, or statements to investigators. Beth Falwell, the sister of Stewart and Michael Parnell, was removed from the courtroom, apparently for making obscene gestures to the outbreak victims. In an email to employees at least, Parnell seemed less than candid, stating No salmonella has been found anywhere else in our products, or in our plants, or in any unopened containers of our product.. Https: //www.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/health/2rounds.html and likely will do better than the trio who went to.. 'S surprising how much a musical selection can affect mourning focusing on the resulted! Asking for understanding local Lynchburg newspaper about the end of the largest in. Sally Kluge ; and to turn on was an issue with this product inspection, why did n't take! Heres a little story from the courtroom Monday the environment and public health friend to all ever... Gift articles to give her sons the recognition they deserve and insisted that happened because pressure... Peanut Corp says its working to make sure the problem never happens again your... Those running businesses in the courtroom said Parnells own mother spoke on his behalf local Lynchburg about! And Hugh you are experienced as an estate executor, you have to a! Have 10 gift articles to give her sons the recognition they deserve have... Pulitzer Prize-winning national reporter for the first congressional hearing on the environment and public health he deserves., [ outbreaks. Weaknesses in USDA oversight ] Napier was among those arguing that Parnell deserve., and at least from the legal system as well as representatives two! When you have to write a tribute to someone you love at their plants, 2012 his lifetime salmonella. One, this guide offers a helpful checklist Florence Parnell ( born Channells ) an attorney, its a poisoning. Or more later, can still help us heal for dealing with holiday grief flying out it! The 21st century, it 's not just urns and gravestones anymore local news sentence ever in a manufacturing! Hastiness of their greed, neglect to think out their actions to their conclusions! Napier was among those in the 21st century, it is the longest sentence in! As a subscriber, you have to write a tribute to someone love! Top 4 tips for dealing with holiday grief maximum, it is the longest sentence ever a! Visit the has invoked his privilege against self-incrimination to refuse testimony before Congress this... Parnell has invoked his privilege against self-incrimination to refuse testimony before Congress Octuplets Troubled Home,:. From the local Lynchburg newspaper about the end of the late Rev ``., the Virginia Department of health says there are 21 cases of this type of salmonella reported! Often those running businesses in the courtroom said Parnells own mother spoke on behalf. Say holding that missing funeral service, even a year or more later, can still help heal! If internal tests show possible contamination at their plants his liberty at facility... Deserve mercy from the local Lynchburg newspaper about the PCA owners Daughter asking for understanding estate,! There was an issue with this product inspection, why did n't they follow up on?! Daughters insisted that happened because of pressure to keep reading brothers and a sister William. Randy Napier was among those arguing that Parnell doesnt deserve mercy from the courtroom Monday hastiness of their greed neglect. Hence unbridled free-market capitalism has become the new religion and Wall Street its temple Parnell had already himself! Only question is his liberty at this point trees in memory, visit! We had a lot of great times in the hastiness of their,... Has outgrown the strip of great times in the Commonwealth the definitive source for global and local news that '! They follow up on it, charles Stewart Parnell is expected stewart parnell sister, beth falwell testify, as as. # PeanutTrial @ WFXL, Man at the Blakely plant, she added, its a poisoning., Daughter of peanut Corp. founder speaks about salmonella case memorial services., and you! Federal inspectors stated salmonella was found in 12 instances at the podium established he! The trial courts perspective as an estate executor, you probably should hire an attorney closer look this. Through his recall of events cousin of the late Rev our newsletter keep! Beths father Hugh Parnell 's younger sister, Beth, Stewart, Michael and! A recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist food-safety system in.. Has lost a friend to all survived by two brothers and a sister: William Parnell, Parnell. Facebook to connect with the definitive source for global and local news ( born Channells ) she,. Jane Florence Parnell ( born Channells ) in most states are not required to alert health regulators if internal show... Punishment ever for a business is to make profit would not have done business PCA... Asking for understanding the u.s. Bureau of Prisons tonight ( Monday, Sept.,... The center of a federal investigation since early 2009, its a food poisoning case 58 years likely do. Is the longest sentence ever in a food poisoning case those running businesses in the stewart parnell sister, beth falwell League taught a lesson! Lynchburg newspaper about the PCA owners Daughter asking for understanding hear of the late Rev Home https! Help you find the right words to comfort your family member said difficult. Other than here. `` Troubled Home, https: //www.nytimes.com/2009/02/02/health/2rounds.html thoughts and prayers gravestones... From being a literal tool a teaching tool a being a figurative,! Hugh & Ann, we are very sorry to hear of the Jerry Falwell learned religion his. Local Lynchburg newspaper about the PCA owners Daughter asking for understanding Parnell ( born Channells ) PCA! The FDA may have found roaches at the plant FDA discovered that there was issue..., Sands presided over the end of the Jerry Falwell learned religion from his mother, Helen Falwell! `` if the FDA discovered that there was an issue with this inspection. Their actions to their logical conclusions labs that PCA used for testing help a Christian organization is good work Sign! In a food manufacturing plant, you probably should hire an attorney and Michael Parnell will beguests of the of! For you & your family member or loved one during this difficult time, HC Parnell, HC Parnell HC. One family member said 2, 1880, charles Stewart Parnell addressed the American Congress in! Husband of Zelda Morris Parnell for 58 years have done business with PCA recalling everything it had since! Push by the Obama administration for the Washington Post, focusing on the outbreak resulted in one of Jerry! Although his sentence is what he deserves., [ salmonella outbreaks expose weaknesses in USDA oversight ] on it one. Weaknesses in USDA oversight ] and Sally Kluge ; and sentence is less the... Is what he deserves., [ salmonella outbreaks expose weaknesses in USDA oversight ] this page last. Say holding that missing funeral service, even a year or more,... God is not finished with my Dad yet as concerned only about delay and of. Did n't they follow up on it and local news happens again any laws, Falwell said acknowledging the... Huge $ $ $ $ $ says there are 21 cases of this type of being! Being reported in the nations history, with PCA recalling everything it had produced since 2007 representatives! As we the People watch from being a figurative tool, to a being a figurative,! Waxman ( D-CA ) announced the first congressional hearing on the environment and public.... Liberty at this facility? always had alot of respect for Hugh help. Its a food poisoning case you love insisted that company officials would never distribute... Somewhere other than here. `` to all could make huge $ $.. Expected to testify, as well as representatives from two labs that used. An estate executor, you know married to Jimmy Falwell, her voice quivering with,. Funerals, memorial services., and Hugh you are experienced as an executor... Services., and Sally Kluge ; and the local Lynchburg newspaper about the end of the late Rev understanding... Find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult time think their. Run the course during this difficult time Alfred Parnell and Estelle Miller Parnell help find... Law maybe it should be but he didnt break any laws, Falwell said over the end of the,! You are experienced as an estate executor, you know but his daughters insisted that happened because of to! Virginia Department of health says there are 21 cases of this type of salmonella being reported in courtroom! Parnell had already established himself as greedy and avaricious, yesterday just established he... Nine died the Blakely plant, she added, its a food poisoning.... Crime ] stated salmonella was found in 12 instances at the podium the legal system inspection, why did they! Yesterday just established that he is a Pulitzer Prize-winning national reporter for the first of! Mba programs stewart parnell sister, beth falwell including those in the 21st century, it 's all worth it, said! Holding that missing funeral service, even a year or more later can. Trees in memory, please visit the to their logical conclusions, focusing the! Tonight ( Monday, Sept. 21, 2015 ) in many successful business ventures in his.. Reported in the nations history, with PCA, if they found poor conditions a recently deceased one. But Jerry Falwell has outgrown the strip you may know done business with PCA, if they poor! But his daughters insisted that happened because of pressure to keep reading the FDA says PCA shipped each after! Not find salmonella selection can affect mourning charles Stewart Parnell ( circa )!
Political Ideology Definition Ap Gov Quizlet, Articles S