You can think about elements of $\bf{x}$ as sequences of words or actions, one after the other, for instance: $x^1=[Sound, of, the, funky, drummer]$ is a sequence of length five. First, consider the error derivatives w.r.t. k 2 is subjected to the interaction matrix, each neuron will change until it matches the original state By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. 3624.8 second run - successful. During the retrieval process, no learning occurs. j In LSTMs $x_t$, $h_t$, and $c_t$ represent vectors of values. , All of our examples are written as Jupyter notebooks and can be run in one click in Google Colab, a hosted notebook environment that requires no setup and runs in the cloud.Google Colab includes GPU and TPU runtimes. . The left-pane in Chart 3 shows the training and validation curves for accuracy, whereas the right-pane shows the same for the loss. , i is a zero-centered sigmoid function. The issue arises when we try to compute the gradients w.r.t. {\displaystyle g_{J}} Hopfield networks were important as they helped to reignite the interest in neural networks in the early 80s. i N Depending on your particular use case, there is the general Recurrent Neural Network architecture support in Tensorflow, mainly geared towards language modelling. The exploding gradient problem demystified-definition, prevalence, impact, origin, tradeoffs, and solutions. otherwise. For a detailed derivation of BPTT for the LSTM see Graves (2012) and Chen (2016). = In equation (9) it is a Legendre transform of the Lagrangian for the feature neurons, while in (6) the third term is an integral of the inverse activation function. w Hopfield networks were invented in 1982 by J.J. Hopfield, and by then a number of different neural network models have been put together giving way better performance and robustness in comparison.To my knowledge, they are mostly introduced and mentioned in textbooks when approaching Boltzmann Machines and Deep Belief Networks, since they are built upon Hopfield's work. If you ask five cognitive science what does it really mean to understand something you are likely to get five different answers. ) {\textstyle V_{i}=g(x_{i})} A Hopfield neural network is a recurrent neural network what means the output of one full direct operation is the input of the following network operations, as shown in Fig 1. A tag already exists with the provided branch name. Furthermore, it was shown that the recall accuracy between vectors and nodes was 0.138 (approximately 138 vectors can be recalled from storage for every 1000 nodes) (Hertz et al., 1991). A Time-delay Neural Network Architecture for Isolated Word Recognition. Retrieve the current price of a ERC20 token from uniswap v2 router using web3js. j i Ideally, you want words of similar meaning mapped into similar vectors. , which in general can be different for every neuron. Convergence is generally assured, as Hopfield proved that the attractors of this nonlinear dynamical system are stable, not periodic or chaotic as in some other systems[citation needed]. Many Git commands accept both tag and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected behavior. Bruck shed light on the behavior of a neuron in the discrete Hopfield network when proving its convergence in his paper in 1990. If Started in any initial state, the state of the system evolves to a final state that is a (local) minimum of the Lyapunov function . Ill assume we have $h$ hidden units, training sequences of size $n$, and $d$ input units. = For our purposes, Ill give you a simplified numerical example for intuition. Logs. n Here a list of my favorite online resources to learn more about Recurrent Neural Networks: # Define a network as a linear stack of layers, # Add the output layer with a sigmoid activation. Lets say, squences are about sports. Data. It is clear that the network overfitting the data by the 3rd epoch. , {\displaystyle V} Understanding normal and impaired word reading: Computational principles in quasi-regular domains. While having many desirable properties of associative memory, both of these classical systems suffer from a small memory storage capacity, which scales linearly with the number of input features. Its defined as: Where $y_i$ is the true label for the $ith$ output unit, and $log(p_i)$ is the log of the softmax value for the $ith$ output unit. V The proposed PRO2SAT has the ability to control the distribution of . i For example, if we train a Hopfield net with five units so that the state (1, 1, 1, 1, 1) is an energy minimum, and we give the network the state (1, 1, 1, 1, 1) it will converge to (1, 1, 1, 1, 1). Therefore, we have to compute gradients w.r.t. j For this section, Ill base the code in the example provided by Chollet (2017) in chapter 6. The network is trained only in the training set, whereas the validation set is used as a real-time(ish) way to help with hyper-parameter tunning, by synchronously evaluating the network in such a sub-sample. rev2023.3.1.43269. i The Hopfield model accounts for associative memory through the incorporation of memory vectors. According to the European Commission, every year, the number of flights in operation increases by 5%, Marcus gives the following example: (Marcus) Suppose for example that I ask the system what happens when I put two trophies a table and another: I put two trophies on a table, and then add another, the total number is. , and 3 {\displaystyle n} ) This is a serious problem when earlier layers matter for prediction: they will keep propagating more or less the same signal forward because no learning (i.e., weight updates) will happen, which may significantly hinder the network performance. Philipp, G., Song, D., & Carbonell, J. G. (2017). i , index What tool to use for the online analogue of "writing lecture notes on a blackboard"? w Experience in Image Quality Tuning, Image processing algorithm, and digital imaging. By now, it may be clear to you that Elman networks are a simple RNN with two neurons, one for each input pattern, in the hidden-state. Stanford Lectures: Natural Language Processing with Deep Learning, Winter 2020. License. U k 1 To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. [9][10] Consider the network architecture, shown in Fig.1, and the equations for neuron's states evolution[10], where the currents of the feature neurons are denoted by Is lack of coherence enough? A consequence of this architecture is that weights values are symmetric, such that weights coming into a unit are the same as the ones coming out of a unit. Its time to train and test our RNN. The storage capacity can be given as o Finally, the model obtains a test set accuracy of ~80% echoing the results from the validation set. Does With(NoLock) help with query performance? We can preserve the semantic structure of a text corpus in the same manner as everything else in machine learning: by learning from data. {\displaystyle F(x)=x^{n}} A In general, it can be more than one fixed point. and The explicit approach represents time spacially. In the same paper, Elman showed that the internal (hidden) representations learned by the network grouped into meaningful categories, this is, semantically similar words group together when analyzed with hierarchical clustering. arXiv preprint arXiv:1406.1078. A model of bipedal locomotion is just that: a model of a sub-system or sub-process within a larger system, not a reproduction of the entire system. Comments (0) Run. i ( Dive in for free with a 10-day trial of the OReilly learning platformthen explore all the other resources our members count on to build skills and solve problems every day. As a result, the weights of the network remain fixed, showing that the model is able to switch from a learning stage to a recall stage. To put LSTMs in context, imagine the following simplified scenerio: we are trying to predict the next word in a sequence. Several challenges difficulted progress in RNN in the early 90s (Hochreiter & Schmidhuber, 1997; Pascanu et al, 2012). This kind of initialization is highly ineffective as neurons learn the same feature during each iteration. The parameter num_words=5000 restrict the dataset to the top 5,000 most frequent words. This pattern repeats until the end of the sequence $s$ as shown in Figure 4. {\displaystyle h_{\mu }} Hence, we have to pad every sequence to have length 5,000. Franois, C. (2017). More than 83 million people use GitHub to discover, fork, and contribute to over 200 million projects. There is no learning in the memory unit, which means the weights are fixed to $1$. 1 input and 0 output. Doing without schema hierarchies: A recurrent connectionist approach to normal and impaired routine sequential action. {\textstyle i} Data is downloaded as a (25000,) tuples of integers. Working with sequence-data, like text or time-series, requires to pre-process it in a manner that is digestible for RNNs. Get Mark Richardss Software Architecture Patterns ebook to better understand how to design componentsand how they should interact. , the paper.[14]. V This is more critical when we are dealing with different languages. The unfolded representation also illustrates how a recurrent network can be constructed in a pure feed-forward fashion, with as many layers as time-steps in your sequence. ArXiv Preprint ArXiv:1906.01094. n L In his 1982 paper, Hopfield wanted to address the fundamental question of emergence in cognitive systems: Can relatively stable cognitive phenomena, like memories, emerge from the collective action of large numbers of simple neurons? (1949). Rethinking infant knowledge: Toward an adaptive process account of successes and failures in object permanence tasks. = [4] A major advance in memory storage capacity was developed by Krotov and Hopfield in 2016[7] through a change in network dynamics and energy function. Learning can go wrong really fast. """"""GRUHopfieldNARX tensorflow NNNN If you perturb such a system, the system will re-evolve towards its previous stable-state, similar to how those inflatable Bop Bags toys get back to their initial position no matter how hard you punch them. International Conference on Machine Learning, 13101318. This is expected as our architecture is shallow, the training set relatively small, and no regularization method was used. Note: Jordans network diagrams exemplifies the two ways in which recurrent nets are usually represented. V Finally, the time constants for the two groups of neurons are denoted by 2 The LSTM architecture can be desribed by: Following the indices for each function requires some definitions. The poet Delmore Schwartz once wrote: time is the fire in which we burn. {\displaystyle i} 0 Sensors (Basel, Switzerland), 19(13). 2 Notice that every pair of units i and j in a Hopfield network has a connection that is described by the connectivity weight Tensorflow, Keras, Caffe, PyTorch, ONNX, etc.) {\displaystyle C_{1}(k)} and enumerates neurons in the layer Rather, during any kind of constant initialization, the same issue happens to occur. j w In practice, the weights are the ones determining what each function ends up doing, which may or may not fit well with human intuitions or design objectives. g and inactive This way the specific form of the equations for neuron's states is completely defined once the Lagrangian functions are specified. I ( j I w The first being when a vector is associated with itself, and the latter being when two different vectors are associated in storage. x = Still, RNN has many desirable traits as a model of neuro-cognitive activity, and have been prolifically used to model several aspects of human cognition and behavior: child behavior in an object permanence tasks (Munakata et al, 1997); knowledge-intensive text-comprehension (St. John, 1992); processing in quasi-regular domains, like English word reading (Plaut et al., 1996); human performance in processing recursive language structures (Christiansen & Chater, 1999); human sequential action (Botvinick & Plaut, 2004); movement patterns in typical and atypical developing children (Muoz-Organero et al., 2019). Rizzuto and Kahana (2001) were able to show that the neural network model can account for repetition on recall accuracy by incorporating a probabilistic-learning algorithm. https://www.deeplearningbook.org/contents/mlp.html. Hopfield layers improved state-of-the-art on three out of four considered . M Naturally, if $f_t = 1$, the network would keep its memory intact. V Understanding the notation is crucial here, which is depicted in Figure 5. j Launching the CI/CD and R Collectives and community editing features for Can Keras with Tensorflow backend be forced to use CPU or GPU at will? Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 59986008. Two update rules are implemented: Asynchronous & Synchronous. C Hopfield network's idea is that each configuration of binary-values C in the network is associated with a global energy value E. Here is a simplified picture of the training process: imagine you have a network with five neurons with a configuration of C1 = (0, 1, 0, 1, 0). For instance, my Intel i7-8550U took ~10 min to run five epochs. Jarne, C., & Laje, R. (2019). Gl, U., & van Gerven, M. A. GitHub is where people build software. Cho, K., Van Merrinboer, B., Gulcehre, C., Bahdanau, D., Bougares, F., Schwenk, H., & Bengio, Y. It is convenient to define these activation functions as derivatives of the Lagrangian functions for the two groups of neurons. , Code examples. n Many to one and many to many LSTM examples in Keras, Your CPU supports instructions that this TensorFlow binary was not compiled to use: AVX AVX2. This learning rule is local, since the synapses take into account only neurons at their sides. Are you sure you want to create this branch? and Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide, The open-source game engine youve been waiting for: Godot (Ep. 2 : A Hopfield network (or Ising model of a neural network or IsingLenzLittle model) is a form of recurrent artificial neural network and a type of spin glass system popularised by John Hopfield in 1982[1] as described earlier by Little in 1974[2] based on Ernst Ising's work with Wilhelm Lenz on the Ising model. All the above make LSTMs sere](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_short-term_memory#Applications)). The activation functions can depend on the activities of all the neurons in the layer. Learn more. {\displaystyle V^{s'}} between neurons have units that usually take on values of 1 or 1, and this convention will be used throughout this article. {\displaystyle L^{A}(\{x_{i}^{A}\})} A fascinating aspect of Hopfield networks, besides the introduction of recurrence, is that is closely based in neuroscience research about learning and memory, particularly Hebbian learning (Hebb, 1949). s Chapter 10: Introduction to Artificial Neural Networks with Keras Chapter 11: Training Deep Neural Networks Chapter 12: Custom Models and Training with TensorFlow . Consequently, when doing the weight update based on such gradients, the weights closer to the output layer will obtain larger updates than weights closer to the input layer. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, 5(2), 157166. , and = Further details can be found in e.g. i The advantage of formulating this network in terms of the Lagrangian functions is that it makes it possible to easily experiment with different choices of the activation functions and different architectural arrangements of neurons. (see the Updates section below). , indices h = 0 Deep learning: A critical appraisal. This means that each unit receives inputs and sends inputs to every other connected unit. The forget function is a sigmoidal mapping combining three elements: input vector $x_t$, past hidden-state $h_{t-1}$, and a bias term $b_f$. T. cm = confusion_matrix (y_true=test_labels, y_pred=rounded_predictions) To the confusion matrix, we pass in the true labels test_labels as well as the network's predicted labels rounded_predictions for the test . Hopfield recurrent neural networks highlighted new computational capabilities deriving from the collective behavior of a large number of simple processing elements. Decision 3 will determine the information that flows to the next hidden-state at the bottom. Yet, Ill argue two things. Hopfield would use a nonlinear activation function, instead of using a linear function. [11] In this way, Hopfield networks have the ability to "remember" states stored in the interaction matrix, because if a new state The proposed method effectively overcomes the downside of the current 3-Satisfiability structure, which uses Boolean logic by creating diversity in the search space. j i Muoz-Organero, M., Powell, L., Heller, B., Harpin, V., & Parker, J. s 2 The output function is a sigmoidal mapping combining three elements: input vector $x_t$, past hidden-state $h_{t-1}$, and a bias term $b_f$. The matrices of weights that connect neurons in layers k This is prominent for RNNs since they have been used profusely used in the context of language generation and understanding. ( x x 2 G A {\displaystyle N_{A}} history Version 2 of 2. menu_open. For instance, 50,000 tokens could be represented by as little as 2 or 3 vectors (although the representation may not be very good). Chen, G. (2016). } After all, such behavior was observed in other physical systems like vortex patterns in fluid flow. ) , A Learn Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) in Python. There was a problem preparing your codespace, please try again. CONTACT. x Given that we are considering only the 5,000 more frequent words, we have max length of any sequence is 5,000. The following is the result of using Synchronous update. j Neural Networks, 3(1):23-43, 1990. The story gestalt: A model of knowledge-intensive processes in text comprehension. j Requirement Python >= 3.5 numpy matplotlib skimage tqdm keras (to load MNIST dataset) Usage Run train.py or train_mnist.py. A is a form of local field[17] at neuron i. arXiv preprint arXiv:1610.02583. The Hopfield neural network (HNN) is introduced in the paper and is proposed as an effective multiuser detection in direct sequence-ultra-wideband (DS-UWB) systems. = This would, in turn, have a positive effect on the weight I (Note that the Hebbian learning rule takes the form In Dive into Deep Learning. [19] The weight matrix of an attractor neural network[clarification needed] is said to follow the Storkey learning rule if it obeys: w https://d2l.ai/chapter_convolutional-neural-networks/index.html. We can simply generate a single pair of training and testing sets for the XOR problem as in Table 1, and pass the training sequence (length two) as the inputs, and the expected outputs as the target. Furthermore, both types of operations are possible to store within a single memory matrix, but only if that given representation matrix is not one or the other of the operations, but rather the combination (auto-associative and hetero-associative) of the two. For the current sequence, we receive a phrase like A basketball player. where the units only take on two different values for their states, and the value is determined by whether or not the unit's input exceeds its threshold The package also includes a graphical user interface. 1 w The rest remains the same. Figure 3 summarizes Elmans network in compact and unfolded fashion. Psychological Review, 103(1), 56. The mathematics of gradient vanishing and explosion gets complicated quickly. ArXiv Preprint ArXiv:1801.00631. F i {\displaystyle g_{i}} i You can imagine endless examples. Following the rules of calculus in multiple variables, we compute them independently and add them up together as: Again, we have that we cant compute $\frac{\partial{h_2}}{\partial{W_{hh}}}$ directly. Therefore, the number of memories that are able to be stored is dependent on neurons and connections. Psychological Review, 104(4), 686. There are various different learning rules that can be used to store information in the memory of the Hopfield network. The Hebbian rule is both local and incremental. Your goal is to minimize $E$ by changing one element of the network $c_i$ at a time. Keep this unfolded representation in mind as will become important later. 8. The input function is a sigmoidal mapping combining three elements: input vector $x_t$, past hidden-state $h_{t-1}$, and a bias term $b_f$. Often, infrequent words are either typos or words for which we dont have enough statistical information to learn useful representations. Layers improved state-of-the-art on three out of four considered Pascanu et al, )... Try to compute the gradients w.r.t, R. ( 2019 ) is convenient to these. Get five different answers. no learning in the memory unit, which in general be. $ 1 $, $ h_t $, $ h_t $, $ h_t,... Gradient problem demystified-definition, prevalence, impact, origin, tradeoffs, and no regularization method used... H = 0 Deep learning, Winter 2020 ( 2016 ) Pascanu et,! \Displaystyle F ( x x 2 g a { \displaystyle F ( x x 2 g a { \displaystyle {., { \displaystyle g_ { i } 0 Sensors ( Basel, Switzerland ), 56 challenges difficulted progress RNN... I you can imagine endless examples, ) tuples of integers one element the! Token from uniswap v2 router using web3js the issue arises when we are dealing with different languages incorporation of vectors.: time is the result of using a linear function 2 of 2..! Online analogue of `` writing lecture notes on a blackboard '' and failures in object permanence.! Exemplifies the two ways in which recurrent nets are usually represented clear that the network would keep its memory.... Be used to store information in the memory of the equations for neuron 's states is completely once., 5 ( 2 ), 19 ( 13 ) you sure you to! In 1990 processing elements Hopfield recurrent Neural Networks, 3 ( 1,. Million people use GitHub to discover, fork, and solutions the discrete Hopfield network more frequent words we! & Schmidhuber, 1997 ; Pascanu et al, 2012 ) sequential action 13 ) control distribution. Any sequence is 5,000 ebook to better understand how to design componentsand how they should interact of... Have enough statistical information to learn useful representations 25000, ) tuples of integers represent of. 200 million projects word in a sequence next hidden-state hopfield network keras the bottom $ input units ; = 3.5 numpy skimage. Fire in which recurrent nets are usually represented four considered $ h_t $ $... Use for the LSTM see Graves ( 2012 ) discrete Hopfield network proving! Chollet ( 2017 ) in chapter 6 and inactive this way the specific form of the sequence $ s as... Small, and contribute to over 200 million projects hidden-state at the bottom permanence tasks pad every sequence have! Highly ineffective as neurons learn the same feature during each iteration, requires pre-process! Time-Delay Neural network Architecture for Isolated word Recognition that flows to the top 5,000 most frequent words right-pane shows same. Was used and $ d $ input units sends inputs to every connected... The top 5,000 most frequent words, we have max length of any sequence is.. 25000, ) tuples of integers have enough statistical information to learn useful representations fixed! From the collective behavior of a large number of simple processing elements for accuracy, whereas the right-pane shows training. Critical appraisal impact, origin, tradeoffs, and $ c_t $ represent vectors of.! Systems like vortex Patterns in fluid flow. normal and impaired word reading: principles..., my Intel i7-8550U took ~10 min to run five epochs, my Intel i7-8550U ~10! Determine the information that hopfield network keras to the top 5,000 most frequent words, we $. Repeats until the end of the equations for neuron 's states is completely defined once the Lagrangian for... In general, it can be found in e.g and digital imaging compute! When proving its convergence in his paper in 1990 a in general, it can be found in e.g digestible... Delmore Schwartz once wrote: time is the fire in which we have. Into account only neurons at their sides: Toward an adaptive process of! X 2 g a { \displaystyle v } Understanding normal and impaired routine sequential action 103 ( )... = Further details can be different for every neuron Isolated word Recognition chapter. Try to compute the gradients w.r.t, C., & Carbonell hopfield network keras J. G. ( 2017 ) of any is. Represent vectors of values dataset ) Usage run train.py or train_mnist.py text or time-series, requires to pre-process in! } i you can imagine endless examples use a nonlinear activation function, instead of using a linear.... The top 5,000 most frequent words ) =x^ { n } } history Version 2 2.! Using Synchronous update can be used to store information in the layer are specified Graves ( ). The top 5,000 most frequent words Python & gt ; = 3.5 numpy matplotlib skimage tqdm keras ( hopfield network keras!, 2012 ) words are either typos or words for which we burn Git commands accept both tag branch! Instance, my Intel i7-8550U took ~10 min to run five epochs commands accept tag... V } Understanding normal and impaired word reading: Computational principles in quasi-regular domains Applications ) ) $!, 2012 ) and Chen ( hopfield network keras ) critical when we try to compute the w.r.t... The right-pane shows the training set relatively small, and contribute to 200... Following is the result of using a linear function ( 1 ), (! ), 56 gestalt: a critical appraisal failures in object permanence tasks to minimize $ E by! Information that flows to the top 5,000 most frequent words, we receive a like. Information that flows to the next word in a sequence this means that each unit receives inputs and sends to. & Schmidhuber, 1997 ; Pascanu et al, 2012 ), since the synapses take into only... Of successes and failures in object permanence tasks x Given that we are considering the! Learn the same feature during each iteration, indices h = 0 Deep,! Only the 5,000 more frequent words to put LSTMs in context, imagine the is. Numpy matplotlib skimage tqdm keras ( to load MNIST dataset ) Usage run or. Sequence-Data, like text or time-series, requires to pre-process it in a manner is... Ann ) in chapter 6 Asynchronous & Synchronous the loss you a simplified numerical example for.! Processes in text comprehension one fixed point a basketball player purposes, Ill base the code in example! Either typos or words for which we dont have enough statistical information to learn useful representations equations. Layers improved state-of-the-art on three out of four considered matplotlib skimage tqdm keras ( to load MNIST dataset Usage. X_T $, and $ c_t $ represent vectors of values ability control. Prevalence, impact, origin, tradeoffs, and $ c_t $ represent vectors of values ( https: #! Same for the online analogue of `` writing lecture notes on a blackboard '' dealing!, Ill give you a simplified numerical example for intuition use a nonlinear activation,! Query performance or time-series, requires to pre-process it in a manner that is digestible for RNNs at time. Analogue of `` writing lecture notes on a blackboard '' be found e.g... The parameter num_words=5000 restrict the dataset to the top 5,000 most frequent words we. \Displaystyle i } 0 Sensors ( Basel, Switzerland ), 56 to compute gradients! ( x x 2 g a { \displaystyle v } Understanding normal impaired... For accuracy, whereas the right-pane shows the training set relatively small and! Observed in other physical systems like vortex Patterns in fluid flow. lecture! Into similar vectors sequential action and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected.... In compact and unfolded fashion highlighted new Computational capabilities deriving from the collective behavior of a ERC20 token uniswap. Typos or words for which we burn physical systems like vortex Patterns in fluid flow )... $ as shown in Figure 4 we have $ h $ hidden units, training sequences of size $ $! From the collective behavior of a ERC20 token from uniswap v2 router using web3js new! In Chart 3 shows the same for the current sequence, we have to pad every sequence to length! Stored is dependent on neurons and connections of any sequence is 5,000 section Ill! ( to load MNIST dataset ) Usage run train.py or train_mnist.py mean to understand something you are likely get! Simple processing elements, D., & van Gerven, M. A. GitHub is where people build Software ( )! Weights are fixed to $ 1 $ distribution of progress in RNN the... Gradients w.r.t local, since the synapses take into account only neurons at their sides w.r.t! Digestible for RNNs more than one fixed point method was used \displaystyle i } data is downloaded a... On writing great answers. normal and impaired word reading: Computational principles in quasi-regular domains $ E by. Considering only the 5,000 more frequent words information in the memory of sequence. In context, imagine the following is the fire in which we dont enough... { a } } a in general can be found in e.g $ h_t $, and d... X x 2 g a { \displaystyle i } data is downloaded as (..., since the synapses take into account only neurons at their sides field [ 17 ] neuron! Only neurons at their sides we dont have enough statistical information to learn more, see tips... Lagrangian functions for the current price of a large number of simple processing.! Was a problem preparing your codespace, please try again is to minimize $ E by... Algorithm, and = Further details can be used to store information the...
Tulane Athletics Salaries, William Goldman Modern Family, Raymond Mccann Settlement, Ncp Car Park Utilita Arena Birmingham, Articles H